Ways to Make Italian Soda. Make and share this Italian Soda recipe from Genius Kitchen. Italian sodas can be a sophisticated thirst quencher or a hit with kids at a picnic a treat they can make themselves. How To Make Italian Soda With Torani SyrupThe combination of syrup, ice, seltzer, and cream can be stirred endless ways all you need are some simple ratios and your imagination. Update We did have the Italian Soda at Evangelines birthday party, and it was an immense hit The kids were all so excited to make their own drinks, and some. Having an Italian themed dinner party Play some Italian music, stick some candles in old wine bottles, and let your guests make their own Italian sodas. My kids. Any time we have family over or a party, we always focus on the food. I dont usually do anything special for drinks. So last month when we had Allisons graduation. How to Make Italian Soda. Bruschetta Bread. Italian soda is a delicious drink thats simple to make and nice to look at. Standard Italian soda is made with club soda and flavored syrup.